Understanding Officer Grade Determinations: What You Need to Know Before Retirement

For many service members, retirement is a long-anticipated milestone after years of dedication and service. However, for officers approaching retirement, an Officer Grade Determination (OGD) can quickly turn a time of celebration into one of uncertainty. If you are an officer nearing retirement and have received notice of an OGD due to adverse administrative action or alleged misconduct during your highest grade, it’s crucial to understand the process and how it could impact your retirement benefits.

This in-depth blog will explain the Officer Grade Determination process, when it is triggered, how each branch handles it, and why it’s critical to have legal representation during this review. We’ll also provide specific citations to each branch’s governing regulations.

What is an Officer Grade Determination (OGD)?

An Officer Grade Determination (OGD) is a process used by the military to determine the appropriate retirement grade for an officer when there is evidence of misconduct or substandard performance in the highest grade held. If an officer is retiring and has been subject to adverse administrative action, or has a record of misconduct or performance concerns in their highest grade, the OGD process is initiated to determine whether the officer should retire at their current rank or a lower grade.

The grade at which you retire will affect your retirement pay, as military retirement benefits are calculated based on the highest grade satisfactorily held. A reduction in grade can significantly lower your retirement pay, which can have long-lasting financial implications.

When is an Officer Grade Determination Triggered?

An OGD is typically triggered when there is a substantiated allegation of adverse information leading to administrative action in the service member’s file related to their performance or conduct at their highest grade. This could include:

• Administrative Disciplinary Actions: Letters of reprimand, counseling statements, or other disciplinary actions.
• Substandard Performance: Performance issues, such as unsatisfactory evaluations or failure to meet the standards expected at the officer’s highest rank.
• Misconduct: Any misconduct or legal infractions that occurred while serving at the highest rank, including allegations of criminal behavior or violations of the Uniform Code of Military Justice (UCMJ).

Even if these incidents occurred years ago, if they are documented in your service record and occurred at your current grade in which you intend to retire, they will likely still trigger an OGD.

Governing Regulations for Officer Grade Determinations by Branch

Each branch of the military has its own regulations governing the OGD process. Here’s a breakdown by branch:

1. Army: In the U.S. Army, the OGD process is governed by Army Regulation 15-80 ("Army Grade Determination Review Board and Grade Determinations"). According to AR 15-80, an OGD is required for officers retiring if they have adverse information or administrative action in their record. The board reviews the officer's service record and determines if they served satisfactorily in the grade they are retiring from.
2. Navy/Marine Corps: The Navy and Marine Corps follow similar guidelines, with OGDs governed by SECNAVINST 1920.6D ("Separation of Regular and Reserve Officers"). The Navy Grade Determination Board conducts reviews of officers with documented misconduct or poor performance. The same process applies to Marine officers under this regulation.
3. Air Force: The Air Force governs the OGD process under AFI 36-3203 ("Service Retirements"). According to AFI 36-3203, the Air Force Grade Determination Review Board (AFGDRB) reviews the records of officers who are retiring with adverse information, with a focus on whether they served satisfactorily at their current grade.
4. Coast Guard: The Coast Guard follows COMDTINST M1850.2C ("Physical Disability Evaluation System Manual") for OGDs. In cases where an officer is retiring with adverse actions or substandard performance, the Coast Guard Grade Determination Board will review whether the officer should retire at their highest rank.

Key Elements of the Officer Grade Determination Process

1. Mandatory Review: Once an officer is identified as subject to an OGD, the review is mandatory. This means that even if the officer is unaware of the potential issue, the military is required to conduct the review before retirement can proceed. This mandatory review ensures that officers only retire at the grade at which they satisfactorily served.
2. Evidence Considered: The OGD Board considers all relevant service records, including performance evaluations, letters of reprimand, disciplinary actions, and any other documentation related to the officer's conduct and performance. The board evaluates whether the officer satisfactorily served in the highest grade, taking into account the nature of the misconduct or substandard performance, the time that has passed since the incident, and any mitigating factors such as post-incident performance or rehabilitation.
3. Standard of Proof: The standard of proof in an OGD review is generally whether the officer served satisfactorily in the highest grade. The board does not need to find evidence of criminal behavior or misconduct beyond a reasonable doubt but rather considers whether the officer’s performance in that grade meets the military’s standards for retirement at that rank.
4. Potential Outcomes: The board may make one of three recommendations:
   • Retire at Current Grade: The officer retires at the grade they held at the time of the review.
   • Retire at a Lower Grade: The board determines that the officer did not serve satisfactorily at their current grade and should retire at a lower grade.
   • Further Investigation: In rare cases, the board may recommend further investigation or delay retirement proceedings pending additional information.

Consequences of a Lower Grade Retirement

Retiring at a lower grade can have significant financial and personal consequences. Military retirement pay is calculated based on the officer’s highest grade satisfactorily held. A reduction in grade from O-6 to O-5, for example, could result in a substantial decrease in retirement pay over the course of a lifetime. Additionally, the retirement grade becomes part of the officer’s official military record, which can affect post-service career opportunities and personal legacy.

How a Veteran Military Attorney Can Help

The OGD process can be daunting, and the stakes are high. Here’s how an experienced attorney with military background can assist you:

1. Reviewing Your Service Record: An attorney will conduct a thorough review of your service record to identify any adverse information that could trigger an OGD. They will help you understand what aspects of your record may pose a risk to your retirement grade and develop a strategy to address those issues.
2. Preparing a Defense: If you are facing an OGD, your attorney can help you gather supporting evidence to demonstrate that you served satisfactorily in your highest grade. This could include letters of recommendation, post-incident performance evaluations, or evidence of rehabilitation efforts. Your attorney will also ensure that mitigating factors are highlighted and that your achievements in your highest grade are emphasized.
3. Advocating to the Board: Your attorney can represent you before the OGD Board, making legal arguments on your behalf and challenging any adverse information that may be improperly interpreted. With an experienced advocate writing your submission, you have a better chance of ensuring that your retirement grade reflects your overall service and dedication.
4. Appealing an Unfavorable Decision: If the board recommends retirement at a lower grade, your attorney can help you appeal the decision through the proper channels. This may involve submitting additional evidence or requesting a review of the board’s findings.

Conclusion: Protect Your Retirement with Skilled Legal Assistance

An Officer Grade Determination can have serious implications for your retirement pay and legacy. If you’re an officer nearing retirement and have received notice of an OGD, it’s critical to act quickly and secure experienced legal counsel to protect your rights and ensure the best possible outcome.

At Patriots Law Group, our veteran attorneys understand the military system and are experienced in handling Officer Grade Determinations. We will guide you through the process, build a strong defense, and advocate on your behalf. Contact us today at 301-952-9000 or schedule a consultation online (CLICK HERE) to ensure your retirement grade reflects the service you’ve earned.

DISCLAIMER:

The information provided in this blog is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Reading or engaging with this content does not establish an attorney-client relationship between you and our law firm. If you need legal assistance regarding your specific situation, we encourage you to contact us directly for a consultation.

Heading 1

Heading 2

Heading 3

Heading 4

Heading 5

Heading 6

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua. Ut enim ad minim veniam, quis nostrud exercitation ullamco laboris nisi ut aliquip ex ea commodo consequat. Duis aute irure dolor in reprehenderit in voluptate velit esse cillum dolore eu fugiat nulla pariatur.

Block quote

Ordered list

1. Item 1
2. Item 2
3. Item 3

Unordered list

• Item A
• Item B
• Item C

Text link

Bold text

Emphasis

^Superscript

_Subscript